
Wine is subjective...sweet!
Uneducated: "Does anybody else taste spearmint gum? Or maybe it's wintergreen...i can't tell"
Educated: "Yes Mr/Ms Winemaker, you are absolutely right, I do taste hints of mint and cedar."
Sometimes those winemaker notes are a unfiltered mouth's godsend.
Uneducated: "Gee , this glass of Grenache smells like flinstones vitamins."
Educated: "I can certainly smell the notes of mineral. Fabulous!"
Speaking of mineral, I had a bottle of 2007 Las Rocas de San Alejandro Garnacha the other day; not at a tasting, but in the privacy of my own home. I actually blurted out, "Honey! This wine smells like flinstones vitamins." I am a bit embarrassed to reveal the previous quote. I realize, however, that I was correct. The wine really did smell like flinstones vitamins, I just didn't have the developed wine vocabulary to connect the correct word with the smell: Mineral. And, I must say that Las Rocas Garnacha is a wonderful bottle of wine. I'd have to agree to Robert Parker and give it a solid 90...or two thumbs up. It was an exciting glass of wine, to say the least. I've never had a glass of grenache before this, but from what I can tell so far, it's pretty wonderful. (Factoid: Grenache is the most planted grape in Spain. It is also grown in other regions like Cali, Australia, and Rhone.) It was very dark red in color, intensely flavored and very dynamic. That makes a wine pretty dang fun to sip on.
Alas, wine tasting is indeed subjective:
With hints of censorship.